By Amanda Kern, Emerald Creative Content
If you work in an industry that’s dedicated to helping people feel better, kudos to you! Considering 1 in 5 U.S. adults, adolescents, and children live with a mental illness, your services are much needed in this world.
And if you’re really good at your job, you might even decide to open up your own mental health practice. In that case, you’re awesome and your patients probably love working with you.
But things can get awkward fast when it comes time to start collecting reviews for marketing on your Google Business Profile. It’s not like you can just ask after a super emotional session.
Can you imagine?!
Sorry things are so hard for you right now, Linda. But hey, when you’re done drying your eyes, would you mind leaving me a 5 star review on Google?
Absolutely not. No way. That would not go over well with Linda or any of your other patients.
On the flip side, maybe a current or former client decides to leave (God forbid) a negative review. Tempting as it may be, you likely can’t respond and explain your perspective on what happened due to industry regulations.
So then what’s a mental health provider and business owner to do when it comes to collecting and managing reviews from patients? Depending on your industry, there are ethical ways you can go about building trust that won’t make you feel icky inside (or break the rules).
Here’s what you need to know about managing reviews for your SEO as a mental health provider or practice owner!
Why Do Mental Health Practices Need Reviews?
Online reviews can improve a mental health practice’s local visibility and help potential clients feel more confident about reaching out. However, therapists cannot manage reviews in the same way as restaurants, retailers, or other service-based businesses.
Asking clients for testimonials, responding to negative feedback, or even thanking someone for a positive review may create ethical and privacy concerns. Before developing a review strategy, mental health professionals must consider confidentiality, professional standards, licensing rules, and the power imbalance within the therapeutic relationship.
What Are the Rules for Reviews For Mental Health Professionals?
Professional standards are not identical across every mental health discipline.
- The American Psychological Association prohibits psychologists from soliciting testimonials from current therapy clients or others who may be vulnerable to undue influence.
- The National Association of Social Workers similarly prohibits soliciting testimonial endorsements from current clients or people who may be vulnerable to pressure.
- American Counseling Association guidance has taken an even more cautious position regarding testimonials from current and former clients. You simply can’t ask.
Before asking anyone for a review, mental health providers should consult:
- Their state licensing board
- The ethics code for their profession
- Their employer or group-practice policies
- Applicable privacy laws
- Their professional liability insurer or attorney when necessary
A strategy that is acceptable for one type of provider may not be appropriate for another. Therapists should not assume that a recommendation found in a general local SEO guide applies to a clinical practice.
Rule #1 – Avoid Pressuring Clients for Positive Reviews
Even when a professional code does not completely prohibit review requests, the way those requests are made matters. Think about how your client feels being asked by the person who is helping them through a tough time…it might be a lot of pressure!
Clients may feel obligated to comply because of the therapist’s authority, their desire to preserve the relationship, or their concern that declining could affect their care.
Avoid asking for a review:
- During an emotionally significant session
- Immediately after a client expresses gratitude
- In exchange for a discount, gift, or other benefit
- In a way that suggests only positive feedback is welcome
- Through repeated personal requests
- When the client may reasonably feel unable to decline
Practices should never write reviews on behalf of clients, create fake profiles, purchase testimonials, or ask employees and family members to pose as clients. The Federal Trade Commission’s Consumer Reviews and Testimonials Rule, which took effect in October 2024, prohibits several deceptive review practices and allows civil penalties for knowing violations.
When review requests are permitted, a neutral and consistent process is generally more appropriate than selectively approaching clients who seem likely to leave five-star feedback.
For example, a practice might include general information about voluntary feedback options in its standard discharge materials rather than personally asking a client to praise the therapist.
Any request should make it clear that:
- Participation is entirely optional
- Declining will not affect care
- Clients should not disclose anything they want to keep private
- Public reviews can reveal their connection to the practice
- The practice may be unable to respond in detail because of confidentiality
Stay up to date with Google’s rules for Google Reviews by checking out the latest Google Business Profile news.
Rule #2 – Never Confirm That a Reviewer Is a Client
Linda (or any other reviewer) may voluntarily state that they received therapy from your practice. But even if they do, that does not give the therapist permission to confirm the relationship, discuss treatment, correct the person’s clinical history, or share any details from private communications.
Even a response such as “We are glad your sessions helped” may confirm that the reviewer received services!
A defensive response to a negative review can create even greater risk if it references appointment attendance, diagnoses, billing, treatment recommendations, conversations, or other protected information. Frustrating for sure, but best to avoid just to be on the safe side.
The U.S. Department of Health and Human Services has taken enforcement action against healthcare organizations that disclosed protected health information while responding to negative online reviews.
Not every therapist or practice is a HIPAA-covered entity, but confidentiality duties may still arise from state law, licensing regulations, professional ethics, contracts, and the therapeutic relationship itself. The safest approach is to treat public review platforms as inappropriate places for discussing individual care.
Rule #3 – Always Use a Standard, Privacy-Conscious Response
Here’s a crazy strategy to apply to managing things people say on the internet: don’t respond back at all.
That’s right! You may choose not to respond to reviews at all. That’s likely a good way to handle reviews if you’re 100% sure what the rules are in your industry.
However, if responses are allowed, and when a response is appropriate, it should usually remain general and avoid confirming whether the reviewer is or was a client.
A neutral response might say:
Thank you for sharing your feedback. Because we protect the privacy of everyone who contacts our practice, we cannot discuss individual experiences in a public forum. We welcome anyone with questions or concerns to contact our office directly.
A response to a negative review might say:
We take feedback seriously and are committed to providing respectful, professional service. To protect privacy, we cannot address individual circumstances here. Please contact our office directly if you would like to discuss a concern.
These responses establish a boundary without denying the person’s experience, becoming defensive, or disclosing confidential information. Practices should create an internal review-response policy so that every team member understands who is authorized to respond and which information must never be shared.
It’s a win-win!
Rule #4 – Don’t Turn Private Feedback Into a Testimonial Without Permission
Linda may send a kind email, thank-you card, or private message describing a positive experience. But that does not automatically make her statement available for use on a website or social media page.
Turning private praise into public marketing can still be considered soliciting or using a testimonial. Removing the client’s name may not solve the ethical issue, particularly if the details could allow the person to recognize themselves or be identified by others.
Therapists should review their professional rules before requesting permission to republish private feedback. In many cases, the safest choice is to appreciate the message privately without using it as promotional content.
Rule #5 – Build Trust With Fellow Provider Testimonials
You probably have specialist referral partners, mentors, and other friends in the industry who trust your expertise. Ask them for testimonials instead of clients! These types of endorsements are huge trust-builders and offer a smart way to get the reviews you need for GEO and SEO without breaking the rules.
Other Ways Mental Health Practices Can Build Trust
Reviews are only one of many factors that can establish credibility. Mental health professionals can help potential clients feel confident in their practice without asking vulnerable people to publicly describe their care.
Alternative trust signals include:
- Detailed provider biographies
- Licensure and credential information
- Clearly explained treatment approaches
- Professional association memberships
- Continuing education and specialized training
- Speaking engagements and workshops
- Articles reviewed or written by qualified clinicians
- Interviews and podcast appearances
- Referrals from community organizations
- Links from reputable professional directories
- Clear information about fees, insurance, availability, and policies
- Photos that help clients understand the office environment
- Answers to common questions about beginning therapy
Build a Marketing Strategy That Protects Trust (and Grows Your Practice)
Marketing a mental health practice requires more than following a generic checklist. You need a strategy that helps the right people find you while respecting client privacy, professional ethics, and the trust your practice has worked so hard to build.
Emerald Creative Content is an experienced Columbus marketing agency that has worked with some of the city’s highest-ranking mental health professionals and practices. We understand how to combine local SEO, GEO, website content, and ethical trust-building strategies to strengthen your online visibility without making your marketing feel uncomfortable or overly promotional.
Book a free 30-minute consultation with Emerald Creative Content to discuss where your practice currently stands, what may be limiting your visibility, and the most effective next steps for reaching more of the people who need your services.
Schedule Your Free 30-Minute Marketing Consultation